Paul Merson Questions Everton Decision as January Exit Agreed for Tyler DiblingPaul Merson has raised concerns over Everton’s handling of one of their brightest young talents

Paul Merson Questions Everton Decision as January Exit Agreed for Tyler Dibling
Paul Merson has raised concerns over Everton’s handling of one of their brightest young talents, insisting the club may be making a costly mistake by allowing Tyler Dibling to leave so early in his development.

According to reports, the Everton board have already agreed a deal that will see Dibling depart during the January transfer window, a decision that has sparked debate among supporters. Merson was clear in his assessment, describing the youngster as a “young hero” and questioning why the Toffees would sanction his exit at such a crucial stage of the season.

“He’s a young hero,” Merson said. “Players like that give you energy, belief, and something different. They shouldn’t be letting him go too soon.”
The news has also reignited a wider conversation about squad depth and player welfare in the modern game. One fan took to social media, posting: “I personally think teams should have plenty of depth. It’s a long season, and you must expect a lot of injuries. Look at Rohl — he should have been taken away, you could see he was badly hurt.”

Although the tweet referenced Leeds United, the message struck a chord with Everton fans, who fear that losing Dibling mid-season could leave the squad short as injuries and fixture congestion begin to mount.
Dibling has been viewed as one of the most exciting young prospects around the club, and his impending departure has left many questioning the club’s long-term strategy. With Everton still navigating a demanding campaign, some supporters believe retaining youthful depth could be vital in maintaining consistency and competitiveness.
As January unfolds and Dibling edges closer to an exit, pressure is building on the Everton hierarchy to justify the decision — and to ensure reinforcements arrive quickly. Otherwise, Merson’s warning that Everton have let a young hero slip away too soon may prove painfully accurate.