Tensions boiled over in the latest Merseyside derby as Everton legend Duncan Ferguson launched a furious criticism of VAR following a contentious decision
Duncan Ferguson Blasts VAR After Controversial Derby Decision as Premier League Responds
Tensions boiled over in the latest Merseyside derby as Everton legend Duncan Ferguson launched a furious criticism of VAR following a contentious decision that denied Iliman Ndiaye a crucial early goal against Liverpool.
The dramatic encounter, played at Everton’s new Hill Dickinson Stadium on Sunday, saw Liverpool snatch a late 2-1 victory in a match packed with controversy and high emotion. Mohamed Salah opened the scoring in the 29th minute, shortly after Ndiaye believed he had handed the hosts the lead. Beto restored parity for Everton in the second half before Virgil van Dijk powered home a stoppage-time winner in the 100th minute to seal all three points for Arne Slot’s side.
However, the defining moment of the match came just before the half-hour mark. Ndiaye tapped in from close range after meeting a cross from Jake O’Brien, sending the home crowd into raptures. Celebrations were cut short when VAR intervened, ruling the goal out after a lengthy review—sparking confusion and outrage among Everton players and supporters alike.
Speaking live on Sky Sports after the match, Ferguson did not hold back in his assessment of the decision.
“That’s not what VAR was brought in for,” Ferguson fumed. “You’re taking away big moments from players and fans. Ndiaye’s been robbed there—absolutely robbed.”
The former Everton striker’s comments quickly gained traction, with many fans echoing his frustration across social media.
In response to the growing controversy, the Premier League released an official statement clarifying the decision. According to the league, the goal was disallowed due to a marginal offside detected in the buildup, with VAR concluding that the attacking phase leading to Ndiaye’s finish did not meet the required threshold for the goal to stand.
Despite the explanation, debate continues to rage over the consistency and application of VAR in high-stakes fixtures. Critics argue that such fine margins undermine the spirit of the game, while supporters insist the technology ensures fairness when applied correctly.
For Everton, the defeat is a bitter pill to swallow—particularly given the significance of what would have been a historic first derby goal at their new home. For Liverpool, meanwhile, it marks another crucial step in their campaign, delivered in the most dramatic fashion.
As the fallout continues, one thing is clear: VAR remains as divisive as ever in the modern game.
